Financial Influencers: Should Platforms Be Liable?

<PodcastEmbed spotifyUrl="https://open.spotify.com/show/2REHyOBFQ8vPJM78atTU0y" appleUrl="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/rocket-agents-podcast/id1807401699" amazonUrl="https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/2d3fa50e-1d28-45fb-a6f9-5a9b5645f5e8/rocket-agents-podcast" />

Financial influencers have become powerful voices shaping investment decisions for millions. But when their advice leads to financial harm, who should be held responsible? A groundbreaking regulatory framework from South Africa is forcing platforms and brands to reconsider their role in the financial content ecosystem.

The FSCA Precedent

South Africa's Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) established a significant precedent in 2024 by holding "both the influencer delivering financial advice and the brand or entity supporting them jointly liable for any financial harm."

This framework represents a major shift in how regulators view the financial influencer landscape. Key requirements include:

• Mandatory disclosure of qualifications and credentials
• Prohibition of misleading claims about investment returns
• Shared accountability across the entire promotional chain
• Transparent sponsorship declarations for all paid partnerships

Global Regulatory Momentum

The FSCA's approach isn't isolated. Similar investigations and regulatory frameworks are underway across major markets:

• United Kingdom: The FCA has increased scrutiny of social media financial promotions
• United States: The SEC continues investigating influencer-promoted securities
• Australia: ASIC has warned platforms about liability for misleading financial content

The Platform Complicity Problem

Social media platforms find themselves at the center of this debate. The core tension is clear: social media algorithms reward engagement—clicks, comments, shares—not truth.

This creates a structural incentive problem:

• Sensational financial claims generate higher engagement
• Platforms profit from monetized financial advice content
• Meanwhile, platforms maintain claims of neutrality as mere hosts
• Users suffer the consequences of misinformation

The Public Risk

The stakes are significant. Research indicates over 60% of Gen Z individuals use TikTok and YouTube as primary sources of financial advice. This creates substantial exposure to:

• Unqualified investment recommendations
• Misleading claims about trading strategies
• Pump-and-dump schemes disguised as tips
• Crypto scams and fraudulent opportunities

For a generation making their first major financial decisions, the consequences of misinformation can be severe and long-lasting.

What Future Regulation May Require

Based on current regulatory trends, platforms and brands should anticipate:

Credential Verification Systems

Platforms may need to verify and display credentials for users providing financial advice, distinguishing qualified professionals from amateur commentators.

Content Badging Standards

Similar to COVID-19 misinformation labels, financial content may require clear badges indicating whether advice comes from licensed professionals or represents personal opinion.

Algorithm Transparency Mandates

Regulators may require platforms to disclose how financial content gets amplified and what engagement metrics drive visibility.

Automated Detection Tools

Investment in AI-powered systems to identify and flag potentially misleading financial claims before they reach wide audiences.

What This Means for Brands

For brands working with financial influencers, the implications are clear:

1. Due diligence is essential - Verify influencer credentials before partnerships
2. Documentation matters - Keep records of compliance reviews and approvals
3. Disclosure must be prominent - Ensure sponsored content is clearly labeled
4. Claims need substantiation - All financial claims require supporting evidence

The Bottom Line

The era of unaccountable financial influencer content is ending. Whether through proactive industry standards or reactive regulatory enforcement, platforms and brands will increasingly share responsibility for the financial advice their ecosystems amplify.

Smart organizations are getting ahead of this shift now—building compliance frameworks, verifying partner credentials, and establishing clear policies for financial content. Those who wait may find themselves facing the same joint liability that South Africa's FSCA has pioneered.

The question isn't whether regulation is coming. It's whether your organization will be ready when it arrives.